How do you define a truth? We say it should be physically observable and be reproducible. Air moves from a high pressure environment to a low pressure one. If there’s an exception, include that exception in the rule, then that truth is consistent.
What about truths you cannot test?

You’d assume we disregard those or treat them with much more caution and nuance. But this is not the case. Society is littered with untestable truths. There are things that are not measurable such as thoughts, the future, and our inner worlds.
You may be thinking of EKGs or fMRI’s, but be careful. The former measures electrical activity and the latter measures bloodflow. They do not measure thoughts themselves. A thought leaves a footprint which can come in those aforementioned forms. Imagine measuring ripples in a pond, and saying that you are measuring the rock that caused them. A fish briefly coming up to the surface could have caused these ripples, it could have been the wind. You cannot be sure it was a rock, and therefore cannot deduce properties about this rock based on its effects on the pond.
Measuring the brain introduces subjectivity. We can see activity in the frontal lobes, which is objective, but we have to ask the person being tested what they felt or what they were thinking to map on what was being measured. The inner human experience will always be subjective.
Our definition of truth does not include subjectivity. There is no subjectivity in the laws of physics. Logic should assume that we shouldn’t abide by truths in the subjective realm. But we do this all the time.

We have many of these in society that are not based on objectivity. You can call these beliefs or wisdom, but I will call them “truths” because of how we abide by them. We cling onto phrases like “women don’t like nice guys” as if they were real and measurable. As if opposing them is as absurd as opposing the concept of gravity. (Aside from the fact that the nature of this specific phrase is widely misunderstood in the first place. Maybe a topic for another post).
Let’s break this example down. It is declarative, X does or doesn’t do Y. It is also all inclusive. Women, meaning every single woman without exception.
First of all, this is not testable. You physically cannot interview every single woman that has lived, lives currently and will live in the future, and track their history of attraction.
Second of all, if even one exception occurs, the truth has lost its status as such. We can include this exception to the rule, but the fact that we cannot measure every subject we want to test renders the exception useless. From a practical lens, we have an infinite amount of subjects to interview, meaning there is theoretically an infinite amount of exceptions.
Lastly, because humans are unique, there is no sample size that we can extrapolate from and expect accuracy in real world interpersonal scenarios. In a human’s life, they are not meeting an amalgamation of statistics and interview data. They are meeting a hyper specific collection of humans, all with their own personalities and quirks. If the data tells us that 20% of people are untrustworthy, that does not mean 20% of who you personally will meet are untrustworthy.
These truths are not quantifiable, yet we let them control our lives. For a society so focused on objectivity, we are deeply driven by unobjective mental models of the world.
When we take phrases like this and treat them as a law, we create more illusion in the world and hinder our own ability to interact with our fellow humans. A “truth” will never tell you anything about an individual. “People don’t change”, is a non measureable “truth” for the reasons mentioned before. But let’s say you treat it as law. How can you possibly project that “truth” onto one person you are interacting with? You are choosing not to respect that person’s unique personality and inner world.
All you are doing is feeding your own insecurities and false sense of control.

Notice how your mind takes an illusory truth and constructs narratives around it.
People never change (“truth”), so I should never trust anyone twice (narrative)
Men just want sex (“truth”), transactional relationships are the only ones possible (narrative)
People can construct different narratives around the same “truths”.
It’s when we relate to these “truths” in a personal way and draw conclusions about us or the way we must live that makes these dangerous.
Then we also have “truths” directly concerning ourselves. “No one likes me”. Can you interview every single person on the earth? No, you have an empirically invalid claim. This isn’t a way to fix your personal belief. These beliefs are fundamentally emotionally charged and cannot be changed by thought experiments or intellect. I point these things out to show that a lot of our internal worlds are in chaos. We have a lot of work to do in order to make a more sane world with less suffering.
If we can all conclude that thoughts exist, but there is no way to measure them, we have to entertain the idea that there is validity to the immaterial. A thought is just one example. There are many immaterial phenomena that have a huge impact on your lives.
This isn’t free reign to peddle conspiracy theories or mysticism, which I’m sure was where many of you thought I would jump to. That in itself highlights the problem. As we lose our personal relationship with the subjective, we start to view it in binary and conjure up the most extreme examples. You are either religious, or you’re not. You either believe in science or you don’t. These are the only choices one is left with if they lack awareness and a relationship to their inner world.
The absence of awareness is where conspiracies form. But in its presence, meaningful internal work can be done. Your engagement with the external world will actually be even more clean and authentic.
We will explore how that can be done in a future post.